I offer this response to various reactions to ongoing debate of the SMFS Derringer Awards. Any organization that gives awards constantly debates fairness. For now, the SMFS has tried to document its fairness with the recent rules change. In the continuing interest of fairness we may need to change things in the future, but we won't realize anything needs to be done if we stop discussion.
For example, the previous regular Derringer process was to sign up to a separate group just to read the Derringer stories, and voting involved e-mailing two volunteer vote counters. In the current process, the Derringer stories are posted to Shortmystery's Files section and the votes are counted by polls created in Shortmystery—allowing a greater portion of the group to find the stories and vote. The change would have never been made if no one brought it up. And if no one brought it up, I'm sure quite a few people would have stood by the previous process because "it's the way we've always done things."
So as heated as these debates get, I see them as ultimately helpful to the SMFS.
From the group keeping mystery & crime stories in the public eye since 1996
Tuesday, September 9, 2008
Sunday, August 31, 2008
Poll Results: Derringer Eligibility for SMFS Officers
By a margin of 38 to 30 votes, SMFS members have voted to amend the Derringer Rules as follows:
To avoid the appearance of any impropriety, Officers of the SMFS executive (president, vice-president, secretary and awards coordinator) will not be eligible for consideration for the Derringers during the terms of their office.
Wednesday, August 6, 2008
How Shortmystery will fight spam
Jim Doherty and I have come up with a policy to deal with the listserv equivalent of spam:
If a post 1) comes from someone unfamiliar to us, who is on moderated status, 2) sounds too canned, and 3) shows no desire to be a part of the community, we will reject it.
Obviously, a long-standing member, talking about a new service, or a new publication s/he's starting, or passing along info on such a service/publication, would be not only welcome to do so, but encouraged to do so.
Labels:
FAQs
Sunday, August 3, 2008
Under Review: SMFS officials' eligibility for Derringer Awards
A two-week discussion period began August 2 on whether the SMFS President, Vice President, and Derringer Coordinator should by rule be ineligible to win Derringer Awards during their terms in office.
The motion as worded by Kevin Burton Smith, seconded by Kevin R. Tipple:
Onlist discussion ends Saturday, August 16, followed by two weeks for a group vote.
The motion as worded by Kevin Burton Smith, seconded by Kevin R. Tipple:
To avoid the appearance of any impropriety, Officers of the SMFS executive (president, vice-president, secretary and awards coordinator) will not be eligible for consideration for the Derringers during the terms of their office.
Onlist discussion ends Saturday, August 16, followed by two weeks for a group vote.
Labels:
Derringers,
FAQs
Wednesday, July 30, 2008
New SMFS Site Layout
The following site layout was approved by group vote ending July 29, 2008
The current front page descriptions of the Derringer Awards and officers' roles will be shifted to the "Awards" and "Officers" pages respectively. The more informal description of the group will be on a new "Members' Welcome" page.
Statement of Purpose
The Short Mystery Fiction Society is a worldwide group of writers, editors, publishers and readers. Through informative discussions, publicity efforts, and annual awards, we promote the creation, publication, and appreciation of short crime and mystery fiction.
Join Us
Subscribe to the free Shortmystery Yahoo! Group. Send an e-mail to Shortmystery-subscribe@yahoogroups.com or visit the Shortmystery subscription page.
The current front page descriptions of the Derringer Awards and officers' roles will be shifted to the "Awards" and "Officers" pages respectively. The more informal description of the group will be on a new "Members' Welcome" page.
Members' Welcome
The Short Mystery Fiction Society includes wonderful and friendly people across the USA and Canada, the UK, India, South America, Australia and other exotic lands.
SMFS members engage in daily discussions about short mystery and crime fiction in particular and fiction writing in general. Ask questions about crime scene technology, police procedures, how PIs really operate, the best way to poison someone, how long does a dead body stay warm, or any other genre-related topic. You'll get answers from qualified experts in the field or from fellow SMFSers who have researched and written about it.
Have a problem with a story you're working on? Not sure how to develop a plot, plant clues and red herrings, add substance and life to your characters? Ask and you'll get help from others who struggle through the same problems with every story they write, whether it's their first or their hundred and first.
Members of SMFS also share information about where the best stories can be found for your reading pleasure, as well as where and how to submit your own stories for publication in this ever-evolving marketplace.
Labels:
FAQs
Tuesday, July 29, 2008
Poll Results: Site Layout, Web Archive, Golden Derringer
Polls on the following issues are now closed:
1) Whether to adopt the proposed new site layout
By a margin of 58-20 votes, the proposed new layout is adopted.
2) Whether to make the list Web archive private
By a margin of 56-28 votes, the Web archive is made private.
3) Whether to rename the Golden Derringer lifetime achievement award in honor of Edward D. Hoch
By a margin of 73-14 votes, the Golden Derringer is renamed the Edward D. Hoch Memorial Golden Derringer.
1) Whether to adopt the proposed new site layout
By a margin of 58-20 votes, the proposed new layout is adopted.
2) Whether to make the list Web archive private
By a margin of 56-28 votes, the Web archive is made private.
3) Whether to rename the Golden Derringer lifetime achievement award in honor of Edward D. Hoch
By a margin of 73-14 votes, the Golden Derringer is renamed the Edward D. Hoch Memorial Golden Derringer.
Saturday, July 19, 2008
Problems Accessing Yahoo! Groups?
If you receive group e-mail but are unable to visit our Yahoo! Groups site or vote in the polls -
Here are two Yahoo! help links:
Q: I'm receiving email from a group, but when I try to visit the group's webpages, it says that I "need to enable web access".
Q: I get Group email, but I’m not in the Member list and I don’t see the Group when I sign into groups.yahoo.com -- what’s up?
If you are in the Member list and can access the Yahoo! Groups site, but have not received messages as expected -
Your account may be "bouncing".
If you are in the Member list and have web access but have not received group email for some time and cannot access the Yahoo! Groups site specifically -
Yahoo! Groups delivery may be delayed or the site may be down. Visit the Official Yahoo! Groups Blog for the most current information.
If you'd like to change the email address where you receive Shortmystery messages -
First, check your Shortmystery membership page. Click on the pencil icon next to "Identity". If your desired email address is listed, click on its option button. Then click on the purple "Save" bar to register the change.
If your desired email address is not listed -
1. Move your mouse pointer over your name in the top right corner of the page. A menu should appear. Click on "Account Info".
2. From your main account page, click on the "Account Security" tab in the left sidebar.
3. Click on "Email Addresses". A pop-up window should appear. Click on "Add recovery email address."
4. Enter your desired email address and click on the blue bar to send yourself a verification email.
5. Once you've verified the new address, you should be able to select it from your Shortmystery membership page under "Identity".
You can also use the Edit Groups page to set any of your other Yahoo! Groups to deliver to the new address.
If you're having an issue not covered above -
Here are two Yahoo! help links:
Q: I'm receiving email from a group, but when I try to visit the group's webpages, it says that I "need to enable web access".
Q: I get Group email, but I’m not in the Member list and I don’t see the Group when I sign into groups.yahoo.com -- what’s up?
If you are in the Member list and can access the Yahoo! Groups site, but have not received messages as expected -
Your account may be "bouncing".
If you are in the Member list and have web access but have not received group email for some time and cannot access the Yahoo! Groups site specifically -
Yahoo! Groups delivery may be delayed or the site may be down. Visit the Official Yahoo! Groups Blog for the most current information.
If you'd like to change the email address where you receive Shortmystery messages -
First, check your Shortmystery membership page. Click on the pencil icon next to "Identity". If your desired email address is listed, click on its option button. Then click on the purple "Save" bar to register the change.
If your desired email address is not listed -
1. Move your mouse pointer over your name in the top right corner of the page. A menu should appear. Click on "Account Info".
2. From your main account page, click on the "Account Security" tab in the left sidebar.
3. Click on "Email Addresses". A pop-up window should appear. Click on "Add recovery email address."
4. Enter your desired email address and click on the blue bar to send yourself a verification email.
5. Once you've verified the new address, you should be able to select it from your Shortmystery membership page under "Identity".
You can also use the Edit Groups page to set any of your other Yahoo! Groups to deliver to the new address.
If you're having an issue not covered above -
Labels:
FAQs
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)